Best Sweet Treats and Dessert Shops in Narragansett

Here in Narragansett, we have a little secret that locals and returning visitors cherish: our dessert shops. While enjoying your stay at one of our charming Narragansett beach rentals, there’s nothing like indulging in a refreshing ice cream cone or a decadent dessert after a long day soaking up the sun.

Whether you’re planning your next trip with Durkin Cottage Realty or just looking for some delightful things to do in Narragansett, we’ve got you covered with our top picks for the best dessert spots in town.

Nana’s Ice Cream

Founded in 1985 at Narragansett Beach by the Wright Family and later taken over by the Mann Family in 2006, this multi-generational family business keeps the community smiling. At the helm is Dianne Mann, who traded her bustling corporate life for the fulfilling madness of running one of the most beloved beach shops in Narragansett.

Located at 28A Pier Market Place, Nana’s Ice Cream is open daily from 10:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. It’s a must-visit for anyone exploring the diverse array of Narragansett restaurants and eateries.

Baron Ice Cream

When in Narragansett, make sure to stop by Baron Ice Cream, a beloved local gem now under new ownership of a local family. Rest assured, they’ve preserved the same delicious, high-quality ice cream we’ve all come to love over the years. With deep community roots and a commitment to tradition, Baron Ice Cream is your go-to spot for a sweet treat. It’s more than just ice cream; it’s an invitation to be a part of Narragansett’s tight-knit shoreline community, where lifelong memories are made.

Carolena’s Bakery

A newer addition to the Narragansett dessert scene, Carolena’s Bakery is a family affair. Inspired by the old Italian recipes of their grandmother, Rick and Jenn Armstrong, along with their young daughters, Caroline and Lena, have created a cozy spot where classic flavors and family love blend seamlessly. From creme brulees to tiramisus, Carolena’s offers a little piece of heaven. Located at 1014 Boston Neck Road and open Wednesday through Sunday from 7:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., this bakery is a charming visit that feels as heartwarming as it tastes, perfect for a stroll from your Narragansett rental.

The Sweet Spot, INC

Based in the beautiful port of Galilee, The Sweet Spot, INC is a family-owned spot known for its delectable homemade ice cream, yogurt, and bakery items. Operating since 2004, they pride themselves on creating every treat onsite with love and care. Recognized as the best ice cream in the Ocean State, it’s also a favorite among those coming and going from Block Island via ferry. Located at 256 Great Island Road and open daily from 6:30 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., The Sweet Spot, INC is a must-visit for those seeking the quintessential Narragansett dessert experience.

Galleria Dolce

If you’re seeking an authentic Italian experience, look no further than Galleria Dolce. Owned and operated by a father-daughter duo, this café combines the art of culinary craftsmanship with the beauty of local artwork. With offerings that range from breakfast options and quick bites for lunch to all-day pastries and, most importantly, gelato, Galleria Dolce is a unique treat in South County. Located at 140 Point Judith Road Unit 13 and open Wednesday through Sunday from 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., this café brings together artistic creativity and authentic Italian flavors in a way that is uniquely Narragansett.

Stay with Durkin Cottage Realty

Narragansett is more than just a destination; it’s a community rich in tradition and simple pleasures. At Durkin Cottage Realty, we invite you to become part of our extended family. When you choose one of our charming waterfront Narragansett vacation rentals, you’re not just booking a place to stay—you’re becoming part of a tradition that values family, community, and the unique coastal charm that Narragansett is proud to share. Book your stay with Durkin Cottage Realty, bring your loved ones, and indulge in the sweet treats Narragansett has to offer!